Know
what to look for when applying for costly construction loans to save money and
avoid long-term headaches.
NATIONAL
REPORT – Construction financing has always been a tough bucket of capital to
access. In fact, securing financing for a ground-up, new-build project is one
of the hardest asks in the hospitality financing world.
There
are many factors influencing this situation. Generally speaking, banks have
been more muted on hospitality projects. So, a larger share of deals is being
executed by debt funds. In turn, this has led to an increase in the cost of capital
and greater pressure for a return on investments.
However,
these added layers of difficulty shouldn’t completely deter developers – there is
capital out there, but like many things, it’s more expensive in 2024.
Construction
costs have elevated significantly and more sharply than costs in other
industries over the past five years. Interest rates are starting to decrease,
but they’re still high. We have also seen some pullback when it comes to
leverage. It used to be that lenders were looking for 70% to 75% leverage, but
today, it’s more like 60% to 65%. Together, this all means that hotel
developers are having to raise more equity, get investors to write bigger
checks, and bring less debt into these deals.
Hospitality
developers need to be able to consider all their options and weigh the possible
pros and cons of their planned approach before going out for a construction
loan. If you’re looking to secure funding for an upcoming project, here are
some details to keep in mind.
1.
Calculate your interest reserves carefully, then leave some extra leeway
Interest
reserves play a critical role in construction loans, and developers should
budget conservatively to ensure those reserves are large enough to mitigate any
extra costs caused by delays and unexpected expenses. If reserves run out
early, a developer may need to secure additional equity, raising overall
project costs. Lenders rarely offer extra funds to cover these overruns. So,
the developer will have to cut those extra checks.
There are
a few ways to calculate interest reserves, but the two main methods lenders use
are estimated and draw schedule.
An
estimated approach, which is common in construction financing, uses a blanket
advance rate to project interest costs.
A draw
schedule, on the other hand, requires a general contractor to outline the
entire budget, as well as a development timeline, specifying the monthly cash
needs for the project. This can be a more accurate calculation of how interest
reserves will likely be used based on actual cash flow, but it still doesn’t
account for possible issues and delays. This is why having a padded interest
reserve is so critical.
2. Hotels typically require a ramp
up period – structure your loan accordingly
While some properties open to high
and sustained occupancy level, it may take between one and two years for a
hotel to stabilize and start bringing in reliable revenue. There are ways to
structure loans that accommodates this ramp up period.
For example, some loans are built
in two parts – construction and post-opening. During the construction phase, borrowers
are typically paying more interest than principal (another reason one might
need padded interest reserves!) and then the moment you open the property, the
loan becomes amortizing.
For
properties that take a year or two to ramp up, developers might face a debt
service shortfall in the first year. To prepare for this, they should consider
including some interest carry in their loan proceeds.
For
example, if debt service for a construction loan in year one is a million
dollars, a developer might allocate an additional half a million dollars to
help offset cash flow from operations.
3. Be aware of hidden costs and
fees
Origination points, exit fees, and
prepayment penalties are all par for the course when it comes to construction
loans. It is incumbent on the developer to seek out the specific details of
these fees. For example, origination fees are commonly 1% of the total loan
amount. For a $1 million loan, that’s $10,000 due at closing.
Another common fee is an exit fee.
Many, many construction loans are refinanced, and exit fees must be considered
during that process as well. A lot of developers don’t necessarily model that
into their loan plan and are caught flat-footed when they find out this fee is
necessary.
Then there are prepayment fees,
which are especially common with debt funds. Most debt funds want to make a
minimum yield on their investment, which they make via interest. If a developer
pays off their loan before they reach that minimum yield, it can result in
fees.
It is possible negotiate some of
these fees down. So, be sure to bring that up before closing on the loan.
4. Don’t forget third-party costs
Developers should also be aware
that loans can come with terms that have nothing to do with payment. Every
lender is different, and some may have more stringent requirements than others.
For example, a loan may require the
borrower to meet a certain level of insurance coverage or pay a third-party to
monitor the construction process. Some lenders require developers to secure a
performance bond on the general contractor heading up your project, which could
be 1.5% to 2% of the loan’s hard costs, making it a really big expense.
Some third-party costs can also be
negotiated. For example, if the general contractor on a $20 million project has
projects worth over $100 million on their balance sheet, there may not be a
need for a performance bond. There’s no question that contractor can deliver a
$20 million project.
5. Plan for the future
Hotel
developers working on ground-up projects should always keep in mind the
possibility of refinancing down the road.
In
fact, most developers will want to refinance out of a high-interest
construction loan within a year or two of the hotel opening and its business
stabilizing. Developers should run the scenario of that refinance so that they
can be confident that they’ll be able to take this step when the time comes.
While
construction financing may be more costly in 2024, it remains available.
Knowing what to look for when applying for your next loan can help you save
money and avoid many headaches in the long run.
Contributed by Ryan Bosch, principal,
Arriba Capital,
Scottsdale, Arizona
The views and opinions expressed in this column
do not necessarily reflect the opinions of Hotel Investment Today or Northstar
Travel Group and its affiliated companies.